Pettable Vs. Certapet: an Honest Comparison

Jackie Benson
Jackie Benson

An official Emotional Support Animal (ESA) Letter verifies that you have a recommendation from your healthcare provider for an emotional support animal to help you cope with symptoms of an emotional or mental disability. This letter provides proof for landlords that your dog, cat, or other furry friend is an assistance animal entitled to a reasonable accommodation under the Fair Housing Act. An official letter is also necessary to qualify for ESA programs offered by some airlines.

Several online services can help you get a genuine ESA document. In this review, we’ll look at Certapet and compare it with another online ESA service: Pettable.

What Is Pettable?

Pettable online esa letter
Image credit: Pettable

Pettable is an online service that facilitates getting a legitimate Emotional Support Animal (ESA) Letter. The website connects each client with a Licensed Mental Health Professional (LMHP) who can determine whether they qualify for an ESA. If so, the LMHP writes an ESA Letter that meets legal regulations.

How Does Pettable Work?

How Pettable Works
Image credit: Pettable

To get an ESA Letter through Pettable, you go through three steps:

  1. Take a 3-minute online prequalification quiz designed to see if you may be eligible for an ESA.
  2. Complete a live consultation with an LMHP who can evaluate your mental or emotional disability and determine if you meet the criteria for an emotional support animal.
  3. Receive a legitimate ESA Letter within 24 hours if the LMHP determines that you qualify.

An emotional support animal letter from Pettable is compliant with state and federal laws.

How Much Does Pettable Cost?

Pettable offers ESA Letters for both housing and travel purposes. Each letter costs $149, but you get a discount if you purchase both. The housing and travel package is $199. Pettable offers a risk-free guarantee – they will refund your entire payment if your ESA Letter doesn’t work for you.

Is Pettable Legit?

Yes. Pettable connects you to a mental health professional who is licensed in your state and knowledgeable about emotional support animals and ESA regulations. This provider requires you to complete a live evaluation with an LMHP before you get your letter, something that scam sites claim isn’t necessary (although it is).

Pettable’s ESA Letters are compliant with the Fair Housing Act (FHA), the Air Carrier Access Act (ACAA), and HIPAA regulations. They are written on official letterhead and include the provider’s license information and signature.

Our Take on Pettable

Pettable is a legitimate website that provides qualified patients with an ESA Letter compliant with relevant federal and state laws. It doesn’t try to sell any unnecessary service, such as “certification” or “registration” for your emotional support dog, cat, or another animal.

The company also provides clients with access to continuing support. Their therapists and customer service professionals can help if your landlord or travel provider questions your ESA Letter. If your ESA Letter doesn’t work as intended, Pettable will refund your money.

Advantages of Pettable

Pettable offers several unique advantages:

  • Online prequalification quiz that asks mental health questions but doesn’t require you to provide your name, birth date, or other personal information
  • Full money-back guarantee
  • Compliant ESA Letters that meet state and federal regulations
  • Top-notch customer support, including email or phone assistance if you get pushback from other parties about your letter
  • Quick turnaround time – you may get your letter in as little as 24 hours after qualifying.

Having access to a dedicated customer service team can be especially helpful if you are worried about presenting your letter to your landlord. Pettable promises that their team is willing to get on a call with your landlord to verify the validity of your letter and the legal protections it provides.

Disadvantages of Pettable

There are some minor drawbacks with Pettable:

  • You must go through the online quiz and provide an email address and phone number to see pricing options.
  • Some user reviews mention receiving numerous marketing emails.
  • You must pay in full before your consultation. However, Pettable will refund 100% of the cost if you don’t end up qualifying for an ESA Letter after speaking with the LMHP.

For most people, the pros of Pettable will likely outweigh the cons.

What Is CertaPet?

Image credit: CertaPet

Certapet is an online provider of ESA Letters and is the “#1 Emotional Support Letter Service,” according to its website. CertaPet’s service is similar to that of Pettable – it connects customers with medical professionals who provide a mental health diagnosis, an emotional support animal recommendation, and a compliant ESA Letter.

How Does CertaPet Work?

How Certapet Works
Image credit: CertaPet

Like Pettable, CertaPet’s process is broken down into three steps:

  1. Take a short online screening test to determine if you’re a good potential candidate for an ESA Letter.
  2. Get evaluated through a telehealth appointment with a licensed therapist or LMHP in your state.
  3. If approved, get a “custom treatment plan” that includes an ESA Letter shipped to you within 48 hours.

How Much Does CertaPet Cost?

CertaPet’s pricing is the same as Pettable’s. A single ESA Letter for either travel or housing purposes is $149. You can choose a package with both letters for a discounted price of $199.

Is CertaPet Legit?

CertaPet claims it is a legitimate service, and its process seems to meet all the legal requirements for prescribing an ESA Letter, including a live evaluation with an LMHP. CertaPet’s letters meet FHA, ACAA, and HIPAA regulations. The website doesn’t advertise any unnecessary services, such as emotional support animal certification.

Our Take on CertaPet

CertaPet seems to provide genuine ESA letters to qualified individuals, and their pricing is relatively competitive. However, it's hard to be confident in their practices (i.e., the quality of their mental health professionals) as well as whether or not the company has your back. They won't guarantee their letters, and if you don't get approved for an ESA, they keep a decent chunk of your initial payment. Additionally, if for some reason you are deemed unresponsive, they have the right to reject you for an ESA and not offer you a full refund.

It's also difficult to tell who actually works at or is behind the company. There are no photos of the team, the company founders, or any of their mental health professionals. Most of the website photography appears to be stock, and the site is generally pretty clunky. The combination of not knowing who is behind the company and certain portions of the service being non-refundable or the potential to outright lose your payment makes us skeptical.

To our knowledge, the letters they produce are legitimate, and their practices meet the right standard. Still, if you’re investing in getting an ESA Letter you can trust, it’s important to feel confident about the provider you are getting it from.

Advantages of CertaPet

Here are some of the benefits of CertaPet:

  • The service is open to Canada and Puerto Rico, in addition to the rest of the USA.
  • The CertaPet site provides a lot of valuable information about ESAs and relevant laws.
  • The process is quick – you can schedule a phone consultation within a couple of days of completing the online quiz.
  • CertaPet offers the option to get evaluated for another type of service animal: a psychiatric service dog.
  • You can print a digital copy of your ESA Letter immediately after qualifying, and you can request a mailed copy as well.

CertaPet’s online process for getting an ESA Letter is simple and straightforward.

Disadvantages of CertaPet

As stated above, CertaPet has several significant disadvantages.

  • You must pay the entire letter fee before completing your evaluation.
  • If you don’t end up qualifying for an ESA Letter after your evaluation, you don’t get a full refund – CertaPet keeps a “consultation fee” of $35.
  • It charges money for multiple support animals plus random extra add-ons.
  • CertaPet’s money-back guarantee only covers the consultation – you can’t get a refund if you qualify for a letter and then it doesn’t work as anticipated.
  • It's not clear who runs the business or that real people are backing it.
  • Their website and product is kind of clunky.

You can likely get a legitimate ESA letter from CertaPet, but you may think twice about purchasing a product from a company that lacks transparency and doesn’t stand behind its product with a money-back guarantee.

Pettable vs. CertaPet

Even though they both help qualified individuals get official ESA Letters, Pettable and Certapet are quite different. Pettable offers ESA and PSD Letters, and it requires clients to go through an initial quiz before seeing prices. CertaPet shows the cost of all its options, but it's not always clear what will happen if your letter does not work or you don’t get approved. Both services require a patient to be evaluated by a medical professional to determine if they qualify for an Emotional Support Animal.

Bottom Line

Pettable is a legitimate, trustworthy source for genuine ESA Letters. The information provided is clear and accurate, and the company offers a full money-back guarantee.

About the author
Jackie Benson
Jackie Benson
Jackie is a freelance writer based in Minnesota and is a frequent contributor to PracticalAdultInsights, where she specializes in topics relating to education, reviews, and health. She enjoys the great outdoors, taking advantage of the four seasons with activities like skiing, kayaking, and camping.